I finished knitting the second piece of my pretty lace-edged sweater yesterday afternoon. According to the pattern, all I needed to do was graft the two pieces together using Kitchener stitch and sew the side seams. I learned to do Kitchener stitch when I knit my pair of socks and felt really confident with my skills, so I dove right in.
After about 10 stitches, I noticed that the grafted section looked weird. That's because K stitch only works if you only have all-knit stitches. If you have purled stitches mixed in, like you do in ribbing, you need another method. So, I carefully undid the grafting, and set off to search the internet for a tutorial.
Alas, I only seemed to come across others asking the same question as me.
So, by this point
three hours had passed and I needed to get to work. At work I sat down with a piece of paper and started drawing out diagrams of knitting needles with knit and purl stitches on them, and then following the basic steps of K stitch, but switching the knit-wise and purl-wise stitches for the purled stitches.
Yes, I know I've lost everyone's interest at this point. Believe me, if my own beautiful, creamy, lacy, ALMOST finished sweater wasn't at stake, I'd be glazing over as well.After several attempts, I finally constructed a feasable plan for grafting knitting in knit2/purl1 ribbing. And here it is!!! (if you don't do kitchener stitch, you may as well ignore this part)
(front needle) knit, slip, purl
(back needle) purl, slip, knit
(fn) knit, slip, knit
(bn) purl, slip, purl
(fn) purl, slip, purl
(bn) knit, slip, knit
When I finished my diagrams and came up with this pattern for ribbed kitchener, I actually hooted and jumped up and down in a circle. It's been a rough couple weeks for me in Coburg and I can honestly say that was the first wave of pure joy I have felt in that long.
Unfortunately, when I came home to try it on a swatch of knitting (I figured I'd test my methods on a wee piece of knitting before tackling the 300-stitch sweater), the pattern was half a stitch off. That means that the knit and purl stitches were offset just slightly so that the grafted piece looked askew.
Needless to say, I was pretty crushed.
But, knitting has taught me to be patient, bull-headed, and resourceful. So I returned to the internet to do more searching for grafting methods. In the next
two and a half hours, I tried approximately six different grafting methods on my swatch knitting, and all to no avail. I also have e-mails in to the woman who wrote the pattern and some other prominent knitting bloggers who seem to know what they're talking about, and I even posted my quandry on the Craigslist craft discussion board. But this all may be in vain, because my research also revealed that when two pieces of knitting are not going in the same direction (mine were knit towards each other, meaning my open stitches are in different directions), ribbing will always be off by a half a stitch.
So, if this is really the case, it seems I am left with a few options:
1) bind off both pieces of knitting and sew them together. I actually tried this option on my swatch (being bull-headed is both a blessing and a curse, really) and it left a really lumpy, non-stretchy line through the swatch
2) bind off with the right-sides facing using a three-needle bind-off. This will leave an unmistakable seam all through the work, but the ribs will be uniform and not offset.
3) use the method I developed myself and block the finished sweater so there isn't a lot of stretch to the ribbing to hide the offset row. This seems like the most feasable option at this point.
It is at times like this when I remember why knitting scarves was so appealing...